The benefits of using stirrers in the recycling and reclamation of aluminum are recognized throughout the industry:
Productivity Use of a stirrer quickly and efficiently brings the entire batch up to optimal temperature, minimizing the melting time and energy spent on the process and maximizing furnace productivity.
Recovery and Melt Loss Aluminum oxidization is minimized due to the increased melting speed and elimination of need to over heat the bath. This brings an increase in recovery and a reduction in melt loss.
Dross Efficient melt means less dross generation.
Environmental-friendliness Due to an increase in melting speed and decrease in use of burner fuel (e.g., natural gas), there is consequently less greenhouse gas emissions.
Uniformity For consistent and predictable product quality, molten aluminum must be thoroughly mixed from top to bottom.
Safety Elimination of the need for manual stirring results in higher safety.
Traditional Technologies
Stirrers can be categorized into two areas:
Pumps
Mechanical Pumps
Mechanical pumps are the most common form of molten aluminum circulation technology used in the industry today, especially in the US. However, while mechanical pumps have a low upfront cost, they suffer from several inherent design deficiencies:
Mechanical pumps require direct contact with molten aluminum. Physical contact wears parts. A typical cost of maintenance and consumable parts can range from $60,000 to $200,000 per year per system.
Mechanical pumps have a small circulation capability and require special install parameters. Furnaces are required to maintain a certain aluminum depth so that mechanical pumps do not suck-in air and oxidize molten aluminum. Pre-heat of the equipment is also required before installation.
Electromagnetic Pumps
A typical electromagnetic pump is a tube type pump surrounded by copper coils. Since the tube has a small diameter of around 6 inches (152 mm), tube clogging becomes one of the major issues users face. In addition, due to the limited size of the tube, the only way to increase the circulation volume is to increase the molten aluminum velocity. This causes unwanted molten aluminum turbulence which leads to aluminum oxidization and an increase in melt loss. A tube type electromagnetic pump also requires a minimum molten aluminum depth before it can be operated. The coils surrounding the tube are necessary because magnetic field/force is generated by running electricity in the coils. This means the coils are generating heat, and therefore, a water pump is required to protect the coils. If the coils are damaged, replacing them is very costly.
Stirrers
Electromagnet stirrers
While electromagnet stirrers are more suited than mechanical pumps for use in large industrial applications, they also are noted for having significant design deficiencies:
Electromagnet stirrers are complicated, a system unto themselves. They require transformers, special control panels, piping, liquid cooling (typically) and fine install tolerances.
Electromagnet stirrers come with copper coils to generate magnetic field/force to circulate molten aluminum. In order to generate magnetic field/force, electricity has to be run in the coils. In other words, electromagnet
stirrers generate heat within their systems, and therefore typically require a water pump to protect the coils. Maintaining the coils and water pump (to de-mineralize water) is challenging and time consuming. If the coils are damaged by heat, replacement and maintenance costs are high. Electromagnet
stirrers have high electrical, running and ongoing maintenance costs, not to mention that high electricity means generation of greenhouse gas such as CO2.
Because of these issues, Electromagnet stirrers cannot easily be retrofitted onto existing furnaces.
The Solution: Magnet Stirrer
As an alternative and solution to the issues associated with mechanical pumps and electromagnet
stirrers, Zmag has developed a magnet stirrer run by a permanent magnet drive. Zmag’s Magnet Stirrer features a revolutionary and patented design which is scalable, efficient and cost effective. The technology provides contactless stirring of molten aluminum and can be easily adapted for use in existing furnaces.